Featured or trusted partner programs and all school search, finder, or match results are for schools that compensate us. Whether the CRNA or the MD degree is the best fit for you depends on your personality and your long-term goals. Press J to jump to the feed. crna vs Md. But it feels so drab compared to becoming a doctor. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that CRNAs earn an average salary of $150,000 to $160,000, depending on location -- more than some primary care doctors make. The major difference between an anesthetist and an anesthesiologist is that one is a nurse and one is a medical doctor. I've heard the market for CRNAs is going to be softening significantly, though, as they're making a ton of them. The study, titled "Surgical Mortality and Type of Anesthesia Provider," analyzed the effect of different types of anesthesia providers on the death rates of Medicare patients undergoing surgery. I know good primary care physicians deep in the game who salivate over CRNA money. I tend to agree with this. nursing vs premed reddit 8 years to become a MD. Patients undergoing significant surgical procedures are typically rendered unconscious for the duration of the surgery by anesthesia. But I also don't want to settle for a life of mediocrity. Also how long have you been a nurse? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Anesthetist Vs. Anesthesiologist. A physician anesthesiologist is a medical doctor who specializes in anesthesia, pain management and critical care medicine. It's funny. 1 Year Minimum in ICU training as a BSN. If you're looking for a challenge just train for triathlons on your weekends and afternoons off while you're making six figures as a CRNA in 2.5 years while all the med students are killing themselves on gen surg rotations and paying for the privilege. Especially in science and nursing classes. I wish I could say "I'm going to be a doctor" or "I'm going to be a CRNA" and shape my life around that goal. During this time I found out I was bipolar. (I don't recommend bipolar disorder to anyone). While CRNA programs are competitive and intense, the cost to earn your degree and time spent working toward your degree are much less than the cost and time it takes to be an anesthesiologist. Home Uncategorized nursing vs premed reddit. From what you wrote it sounds like you really want dat MD/DO. Working as a certified registered nurse anesthetist (CRNA) could be the perfect solution for your healthcare career aspirations. Salary Comparison Between AA and CRNA. RN currently working in the ICU. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. It depends on whether you want to be a doctor or a nurse. CRNA vs MD Discussion. you have 5 min to win someone's trust over so you better be personable af. Anesthesia resident here: you'd be out of your mind to go to medical school. Hi community. I fucking hated school because it was so all consuming. According to the American Association of Nurse Anesthetists (AANA), nurses first gave anesthesia to wounded soldiers during the Civil War. I'm not seeing much of a difference here? NP vs CRNA (Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist) October 26, 2020 | Staff Writers Advertisement NursePractitionerSchools.com is an advertising-supported site. Posted by 1 year ago. This is such an immature way of thinking and ties into what I just said. I have been accepted by crna program and also a medical school in Caribbean. So here's my story: Right out of high school I chose to pursue a bachelor's degree in video production. My life basically fell apart during this period, I lost alot of friends and made alot of bad decisions due to my untreated illness. But the thought of becoming an MD lights a fire in my belly. It's a very focused part of medicine and very different than most other specialties. Being the "decider" of medical decisions is hardly what it's about - any computer can do that, as they already can - it's about how you deliver healthcare to the patient, and advocate on their behalf. Everyone answers to someone. You shouldn't rush into a big decision such as this, especially if you think that your interest in being a doctor is due to the glamorous way it is portrayed in the media. I love working with patients. That might have a lot to do with your decision depending on life circumstances. You won't be too old for either one of them, and you'll have given yourself the chance to make the right decision for you. I would probably need to take 1-2 years of prereqs to get into medical school + the 8 years of additional training. A certified registered nurse anesthetist (CRNA) is an advanced-practice nurse who is certified in anesthesia. For one you mentioned you love working with patients, and CRNAs/Anesthesiologists mostly work with people who are asleep lol. I also don't want children, which made the decision of MD vs PA for me magnificently easier. If you want to be a physician and also deliver anesthesia, then med school is … According to the latest numbers, “Primary care doctors were offered an average base salary of $173,000 in 2009 compared to an average base salary of $189,000 offered to certified nurse anesthetists, or CRNAs, according to the latest numbers from Merritt Hawkins & Associates, a physician recruiting and consulting firm.” Typically when applicants cite their last xxx hours they do so because their first xxx hours are weak. This is the most common … With only a handful of states paying above the national average, the opportunities for economic advancement by moving to a new locationas a CRNA is a decision to make with some caution. If you'd be happy as an anesthetist just do that. That being said CRNA school is MUCH more attainable at this point. It's not the glamorous job it's made out to be, and I personally think that until someone gets their head around that reality, they are not well-informed enough or mature enough to make the decision to go to medical school. You're probably right about being patient. in nursing, and would love to persue a CRNA … You might catch up in 25 years, but the headaches wouldn't be worth it. I was married and older when I entered grad school. If I were unattached, young, etc. I was an RN but I wanted to be a doctor, so now I'm in medical school. i have a dilemma and don't know what to do. ever consider PA school? There are too many programs and rapidly shrinking demand. Reddit's home for wholesome discussion related to pre-medical studies. seems like you would get the same amount of fulfillment without the many extra years of training post med school graduation. Already, it is legal in 15 states for CRNA’s to dispense anesthesia without the overarching supervision of a … TLDR; Bipolar disorder wreaked havoc on early 20s, got life together and became an RN, trying to decide what to do next. Based on this info, it seems like you are trying to rush and have a goal for the sake of having a goal...that's not the way to figure this out, and a hasty decision either way can haunt you. I'm a CRNA. Seriously, I can't believe that you would imply that. If you're after the $, go the crna route and don't look back. Unless you have your heart set on some other specialty, med school and residency will put you about $1million behind. Only been a nurse since May. It's not just the money. One year after graduating with my video production degree I was miserable, out of work and decided to try a job in an assisted living place. But I also don't want to settle for a life of mediocrity. So I've worked with crashing patients and seen some intense stuff. You know yourself best, and if this is a concern then, like I said in another comment on this post--you owe it to yourself to give yourself the time to really reflect and make the best decision. This is a highly moderated subreddit. Get your GPA up. From that you can specialize in whatever. Specialties CRNA. “While some anesthetists realize anesthesiologists provide valuable contributions, there are some anesthetists who are reluctant to admit they need help and see it as a sign of professional failure resulting in squandered opportunity.” The median cost of a public CRNA program is $40,195 and the median cost of a private program is $60,941, with an overall median of $51,720. Sometimes anesthesia is provided by a physician known as an anesthesiologist. My plan is to switch to an ICU in the next year. Why don't you make it your goal for the next 2 years to learn the most you can about nursing and the medical field, and through that figure out what you want to do? if you like anesthesia CRNA or AA are both good careers. Additionally, those grades.... My program was very competitive. It should be Anesthesiology vs MD since that's the path you'd be taking. there's a ton of patient interaction. I love reading their histories and trying to figure out what is going on in their bodies. Significantly, Massachusetts has a very active CRNA job market as there are several companies currently hiring for this type of role. So med school plus residency is at least 7 years plus a significantly higher loan burden and CRNA school is 2.5 years if you've already got the ICU experience. I would do med school. I'm single, have some college loans and a good GPA. If you’re considering your Master of Science in Nurse Anesthesia, there are many benefits to choosing this option over becoming an anesthesiologist. Ever since my anatomy and physiology course its been in the back of my mind. For the CRNAs out there, what was it that led you to make the choice to become CRNAs vs. anesthesiologist. it would bore me to tears. i checked the school and most students who graduate from it end up in family medicine. there is a ton of patient interaction in anesthesia. This being said I'm afraid that becoming a doctor is a delusion of grandeur, much like my original choice to pursue video production (I wanted to be the next wes anderson). Around this time I also got on bipolar medication, quit smoking and completely turned my life around. Medical school and CRNA school will still be there. they both have pros and cons i just cannot make my mind. The CRNA route can make an incredible difference in the lives of patients, easily as much as an MD. This. It took me 5 years to complete. The fact that you're torn about this decision is okay and normal--it just means that you need time to make the best decision for yourself. Today, nurse anesthetists work in a variety of settings such as: Any insight or advice is greatly appreciated. I had traded in the speculum for a laryngoscope and had no idea what I was doing. I decided to become a nurse, which was easy as I had the guidance of my mom and sister who are both in the field. Okay I know there are many threads asking the same question but from what Ive seen theyre from pre nursing students who havent even gotten into either schools. I can hardly believe how good life is now compared to the torment I endured in college dealing with mood episodes, broken relationships etc. I keep coming back to the thought of becoming a doctor. Pre medicine bachelors degree completed last year. You are still young and you still have time. 9. Posted Feb 7, 2016. erkantarik. I think that it is interesting that the original post said that it was unfair to call CRNA’s with a Doctorate a Doctor because of the MD’s that devote a decade to to study because the CRNA’s spend a similar amount of time in school. CRNA is much quicker from where you're standing now. Rough estimates have anesthesiologists earning an average of $360,000 while CRNAs (specialty nurses in anesthesiology) average about $170,000, which is … What’s your critical care experience like? Most of us are familiar with the medical designation MD (Doctor of Medicine) which we have seen countless times on office doors, medical directories, and even TV shows like Marcus Welby, MD, Trapper John, MD, and Doogie Howser, MD. CRNA is clearly a better option practically. Keyword CPC PCC Volume Score; crna vs anesthesiologists: 0. CRNA school would be a simple 3 years. You need to take time to mature and reflect on the medical field. Besides the Initials MD, vs CRNA what are the practicing differerences between a CRNA and and anesthesiologist. Anesthesiologist: 4 years medical school, 4 years of residency. Of course nurses are extremely important. I'm an MS1 who's consigned himself to the career, which is fine because I love it. Job security is in the toilet for CRNAs. Nurses are amazing and extremely important. Also you said the idea of being a doctor "lights a fire" in you. CRNA: 2 years BSN, 3 years getting required experience, 2.5 years school. Anesthesia made more sense for me then; Although I would have preferred the greater autonomy and professional clout a medical degree confers. There is a lot for you to learn right now and also a lot of opportunities to take working in different fields, and I feel like taking the proper time to explore the field will naturally give you the answer. I guess part of me just misses having a set goal (like I had during nursing school). Does anyone have any thoughts on this? Your comparison here shouldn't be CRNA vs MD. I have 185 total credit hours from my two combined degrees... What is your cumulative GPA? We carefully screen our patients to make sure that the local anesthesia experience will be the right choice. oh guess what now the case is under a spinal, so now you have an awake conscious person staring at you behind the curtain. I spent intern year in various disciplines of medicine and surgery and actually enjoyed experiencing the different specialties. Why didn't you go NP OR PA? I love the science behind it. Cumulative GPA of 3.3 -3.5 gpa in my last 71 hours of college. Working in a busy cardiothoracic ICU is probably a good first step prior to making this decision. It took me 5 years to complete. I'm now 28 and have since graduated with my RN and am working in a hospital. I don't know that there's a greater degree of autonomy. If I want to become an MD now is the time. This is contrasted with MDs, where there are too few programs and a massive demand that isn't going away. Reimbursement is decreasing for MDs, but those loan prices are only going up (and are no longer interest-free during school). “When there is an anesthesia complication, one usually has only seconds or minutes to respond,” he said. I know a few folks with dual certification( CRNA/NP or PA/AA) and they have a much broader scope of practice as they are basically utilized as intensivists and can cover OR/ICU/CCU/Pain Clinic/ER consults, etc. Follow your hearts desire!! Any truth to this? The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. /r/medicine is a virtual lounge for physicians and other medical professionals from around the world to talk about the latest advances, controversies, ask questions of each other, have a laugh, or share a difficult moment. I just mean mediocrity in the sense that CRNA is the easy option in my case. And the CRNA plan is assuming you can actually get 1 year full-time ICU experience that quickly out of school. Being a nurse isn't being mediocre. From a medical school perspective, your last 71 hours of GPA isn't strong. While CRNA is a great career option I dislike the idea of being stuck in a very narrow role, as well as still having to refer to a doctor's opinion for so much. Also I am finishing my B.S. there's just not long-term follow up Minimum 2 years for RN, 2 years for BSN. Please read the rules carefully before posting or commenting. I work on a cardiac med surg units which is step down from the ICU at a smaller suburban hospital. CRNA vs MD Discussion. At this point CRNA man....the money is amazing, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Rural America: CRNAs represent more than 80% of the anesthesia providers in rural counties.Many rural hospitals are critical access hospitals, which often rely on independently practicing CRNAs for anesthesia care. Right now I feel like I am spinning my wheels. If you want to deliver anesthesia to patients and get to that route by the shorter route time wise, then CRNA is the answer. Just wanting opinion on med students, and pre-med applicants on what your opinions are. It might be good to exercise patience and spend a few years as a nurse before you make any costly decisions like higher education. That's not real life. well either way I would say stick with it unless you are a first year, life does get a lot better once you are out of school. CRNAs make okay money, but MDs make serious money, especially if you specialize in something like, say, anesthesia. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. It helps if you like it as a specialty. I think I would love being a cRNa, but I also have a part of me that really wants to pursue medicine to the challenge, and for the accomplishment to know that I will be able to help people everyday from a physician stand-point. I can't imagine a cooler outcome of my life or a job that would be more interesting or satisfying. Have you shadowed a CRNA or an Anesthesiologist? u/lotrfan12345, if you only started working as a nurse since May, you wont have a good idea of whether nursing is a good fit until a couple of years in. Don't rush and rob yourself of the time and reflection that it takes to truly decide what path will make you happiest and align with your ultimate goals.